Im Fokus

Schroders Recession Dashboard: why we’re on high alert


The US Federal Reserve (Fed) has raised the target range for its main policy interest rate five-fold in the past four months. This has set alight the Schroders Recession Dashboard, which is now flashing red, warning of an imminent downturn in the world’s largest economy.

The dashboard offers a balanced way of monitoring recession risks, which would not be possible by focussing on any one measure. That said, the very strong signal of recession currently emanating from the ‘monetary’ indicators is eye-catching, and worth exploring in detail.

All eyes on Fed as it prioritises taming inflation

Of the six monetary indicators that we track, five are currently flashing red (see highlighted section of table, below). Quite a turnaround from the spring when none were signalling recession. This suggests to us that the Fed’s actions are materially impacting the rate of growth in the quantity of money, or 'money supply', flowing around the US economy.

In other words, the central bank is bringing about 'monetary tightening' at such a pace that a recession will be the very likely cost of reducing inflation from a four-decade high. As a result, markets are currently intensely focused on whether the Fed will opt for a third consecutive 0.75% increase in interest rates at its meeting this week (20-21 September).

Chart_1_final.jpg

Scroll to the end of article for more details of how monetary tightening affects the economy - see ‘Schroders Recession Dashboard – tracking the economic cycle’.

Back in the spring many of the dashboard’s ‘inflationary’ indicators had begun flashing red (see highlighted section of chart, below). They were suggesting that capacity was running short in the US economy and it was overheating – most clearly reflected in the indicators tracking the (ongoing) strength of the jobs market.

Chart_2_final.jpg

The Fed has responded to higher inflation with higher interest rates, as per the playbook of economic cycles prior to the Global Financial Crisis. But it’s the speed of the response this time that has caused almost all (more than 80%) of the monetary indicators to turn red in very short order.

Barring the Great Recession of 2008 to 2009, this is the highest reading in three decades. Monetary indicators tend to point towards recession five to 13 months down the line.

Such an outcome would be consistent with the  baseline forecast of the Schroders Economics Team for a recession in the US next year (see: Why recession looms for the developed world).

Significant proportion of dashboard indicators cross key threshold

There have been points in 2022 when individual dashboard indicators have flashed red, however focussing on any one measure does not give a balanced picture.

The inversion of yield curves last spring generated much discussion about recession (see: Schroders Recession Dashboard: what is it telling us?). Then in early summer, the start of a bear market in US stocks dominated commentary.

The dashboard does track the short-term performance of the S&P 500 (see ‘near-term macro and financial markets’ indicators). But, as we explained at the time, past bear markets have not always foretold recession (see: Do bear markets herald a recession?).

Since then, however, the number of variables flashing a recession warning has crossed a key threshold  (see chart, below). Back in April, just under 40% (7 out of 20) of indicators were signalling recession risk. This jumped to 60% (12 out of 20) at the end of August.

Chart_3_final.jpg

US recessions have typically followed when more than 40% of the indicators flashed red. The exception being towards the end of 1995 when the threshold was breached but a US recession avoided, albeit growth materially slowed.

Looking ahead, most near-term macro and financial market indicators flash red when recession is about to happen, typically a month in advance.

We will continue to closely monitor the Schroders Recession Dashboard and keep readers regularly updated with any new developments.

Schroders Recession Dashboard – tracking the economic cycle

The dashboard can give us an indication of where an economy is in the 'economic cycle'. This is the period in which an economy moves from a state of expansion to one of contraction, before expanding again.

We monitor three broad categories of indicator to help guide us as to when a cycle might be entering its contraction, or recessionary, stage. There is a logical ordering of the dashboard indicators, into 'inflationary', 'monetary' and 'near-term macro and financial markets' categories (see below).

Economic cycles since the Global Financial Crisis have differed to those of the past due to the very low inflation and interest rate environment, and more recently Covid-19 distortions.

However prior to this, all US recessions between the 1970s and 90s were preceded by a pick up in inflation and interest rates (see: A snapshot of the global economy in April 2022).

  • Inflationary indicators provide early warning signals that the US economy is at full capacity and overheating. They have typically flashed recession risk around 15 months to 24 months before past recessions.
  • Monetary As inflationary pressures accelerate, this eventually triggers the Federal Reserve to tighten monetary policy. The monetary indicators are then impacted as the central bank hikes interest rates. They have typical lead times of between five to 13 months.
  • Near-term macro and financial markets At some point, increasing interest rates take their toll on economic activity and this hits market sentiment. This category is the last to signal recession risks, as most of the indicators flash red when recession is about to happen, typically a month in advance.

Wichtige Informationen: Bei dieser Mitteilung handelt es sich um Marketingmaterial. Die Einschätzungen und Meinungen in diesem Dokument geben die Auffassung des Autors bzw. der Autoren auf dieser Seite wieder und stimmen nicht zwangsläufig mit Ansichten überein, die in anderen Veröffentlichungen, Strategien oder Fonds von Schroders zum Ausdruck kommen. Dieses Material dient ausschliesslich zu Informationszwecken und ist in keiner Hinsicht als Werbematerial gedacht. Das Dokument stellt weder ein Angebot noch eine Aufforderung zum Kauf oder Verkauf eines Finanzinstruments dar. Es ist weder als Beratung in buchhalterischen, rechtlichen oder steuerlichen Fragen noch als Anlageempfehlung gedacht und sollte nicht für diese Zwecke genutzt werden. Die Ansichten und Informationen in diesem Dokument sollten nicht als Grundlage für einzelne Anlage- und/oder strategische Entscheidungen dienen. Die Wertentwicklung in der Vergangenheit ist kein verlässlicher Indikator für künftige Ergebnisse. Der Wert einer Anlage kann sowohl steigen als auch fallen und ist nicht garantiert. Alle Anlagen sind mit Risiken verbunden. Dazu gehört unter anderem der mögliche Verlust des investierten Kapitals. Die hierin aufgeführten Informationen gelten als zuverlässig. Schroders garantiert jedoch nicht deren Vollständigkeit oder Richtigkeit. Einige der hierin enthaltenen Informationen stammen aus externen Quellen, die von uns als zuverlässig erachtet werden. Für Fehler oder Meinungen Dritter wird keine Verantwortung übernommen. Darüber hinaus können sich diese Daten im Einklang mit den Marktbedingungen ändern. Dies schliesst jedoch keine Verpflichtung oder Haftung aus, die Schroders gegenüber seinen Kunden gemäss etwaig geltender aufsichtsrechtlicher Vorschriften wahrnimmt. Die aufgeführten Regionen/Sektoren dienen nur zur Veranschaulichung und stellen keine Empfehlung zum Kauf oder Verkauf dar. Die im vorliegenden Dokument geäusserten Meinungen enthalten einige Prognosen. Unseres Erachtens stützen sich unsere Erwartungen und Überzeugungen auf plausible Annahmen, die unserem derzeitigen Wissensstand entsprechen. Es gibt jedoch keine Garantie, dass sich etwaige Prognosen oder Meinungen als richtig erweisen. Diese Einschätzungen oder Meinungen können sich ändern.  Herausgeber dieses Dokuments: Schroder Investment Management Limited, 1 London Wall Place, London EC2Y 5AU, Grossbritannien. Registriert in England unter der Nr. 1893220. Zugelassen und beaufsichtigt durch die Financial Conduct Authority.

Kontakt Schroders Wealth Management

Wenn Sie Ihre Anlagebedürfnisse besprechen oder mehr über unsere Dienstleistungen erfahren möchten und darüber, wie wir Ihnen helfen können, wenden Sie sich bitte an uns:

Marc Brodard

Marc Brodard

Head Private Clients - Switzerland
Telefon:
marc.brodard@schroders.com
Isabelle Blöchlinger-Brechbühl

Isabelle Blöchlinger-Brechbühl

Head Swiss German Clients & IAM
Telefon:
Isabelle.Bloechlinger@schroders.com