A red light is flashing over "bond proxy" income funds

Stocks from "bond proxy" sectors such as tobacco could be bad for your wealth, but many income funds are full of them.



Nick Kirrage
Co-head Global Value Team

Since the credit crisis, investor appetite for stocks in companies that appear safe and stable has pushed their prices up to a level where they can no longer be considered safe or stable. This has created a "bond proxy paradox".

Many income funds have taken what we believe are dangerous bond-proxy bets, concentrating investment in traditionally defensive sectors such as food & beverages and tobacco for their income streams. In doing so, they have been risking their investors’ capital.

While stock prices in these sectors have cooled a little recently, valuations remain extremely high. This means that investors in funds with high exposure in this area could face significant losses on current valuations, if they revert to a more normal level.

The lines on the charts below show the relative cyclically-adjusted price to earnings (CAPE) valuation of the banks and tobacco sectors. On the right-hand side of the charts you can see the dividend yield of each sector shown as a percentage.

The UK:


On a global basis:


Even after last month’s fall, the tobacco sector is towards the upper end of its historic valuation range. Conversely, banks are trading at a significant discount to the wider market – and yet, as a sector, banks are paying an average dividend yield which is similar to what’s on offer from tobacco stocks. 

Valuation protection

The focus of the Schroders Value Team on valuation means that both our UK and Global Income portfolios are positioned very differently from most other income funds. Our preference for banks – a sector where most income investors still fear to tread, but where the prospects for income and capital growth are compelling – is a good example of this.

Find out more at The Value Perspective.

Subscribe to our Insights

Visit our preference center, where you can choose which Schroders Insights you would like to receive

The views and opinions contained herein are those of Schroders’ investment teams and/or Economics Group, and do not necessarily represent Schroder Investment Management North America Inc.’s house views. These views are subject to change. This information is intended to be for information purposes only and it is not intended as promotional material in any respect.


Nick Kirrage
Co-head Global Value Team


Please consider a fund's investment objectives, risks, charges and expenses carefully before investing. The Schroder mutual funds (the “Funds”) are distributed by The Hartford Funds, a member of FINRA. To obtain product risk and other information on any Schroders Fund, please click the following link. Read the prospectus carefully before investing. To obtain any further information call your financial advisor or call The Hartford Funds at 1-800-456-7526 for Individual Investors.  The Hartford Funds is not an affiliate of Schroders plc.

Schroder Investment Management North America Inc. (“SIMNA”) is an SEC registered investment adviser, CRD Number 105820, providing asset management products and services to clients in the US and registered as a Portfolio Manager with the securities regulatory authorities in Canada.  Schroder Fund Advisors LLC (“SFA”) is a wholly-owned subsidiary of SIMNA Inc. and is registered as a limited purpose broker-dealer with FINRA and as an Exempt Market Dealer with the securities regulatory authorities in Canada.  SFA markets certain investment vehicles for which other Schroders entities are investment advisers.

For illustrative purposes only and does not constitute a recommendation to invest in the above-mentioned security/sector/country.

Schroders Capital is the private markets investment division of Schroders plc. Schroders Capital Management (US) Inc. (‘Schroders Capital US’) is registered as an investment adviser with the US Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC).It provides asset management products and services to clients in the United States and Canada.For more information, visit www.schroderscapital.com

SIMNA, SFA and Schroders Capital are wholly owned subsidiaries of Schroders plc.